Pages

Showing posts with label Historical Fiction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Historical Fiction. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 6, 2021

Review: Strongheart by Jim Fergus

My chest is heavy and I feel raw as I sit down to write my review for the final novel in the One Thousand White Women trilogy. I feel as if I've just said goodbye to dear friends, knowing I will never see them again. The journals of these remarkable ladies will stay with me for a long time. 

Strongheart continues to follow the native and white women characters that readers fell in love with in the first two books, including the beloved May Dodd (who did not die after the morning massacre on her village like we were led to believe).  Old favorites make their way back into the story and new characters are introduced (I can't tell you how much I loved Chance). The narrative alternatives between the past -through the journals of May and Molly, and the present- through J.W.'s relationship with Molly Standing Bear. I didn't want the say goodbye to these characters, so while the narratives were wrapped up very nicely, it was bittersweet.

The one downfall of historical fiction, I suppose, is that we already know how the big picture ends. The white settlers conquer the last of the native tribes and force them to assimilate into the white way of life or live on reservations in deplorable conditions. This reality is a heavy cloud over the future of those characters who choose to continue their fight against the U.S. government. While I didn't particularly connect with J.W.'s storyline as much as the women's, I appreciated that Fergus used Molly Standing Bear to share the realities of modern reservation life and crimes against native women. I don't think most people are aware of the statistics shared in the novel since it's not often focused on in the press. 

I think most readers will be satisfied with how Fergus ties everything together and ends this exceptional trilogy. It pains me to say this, but if I compare it to the other books in the series, this was my least favorite overall for a few reasons. First off, I would say that J.W. and Molly's relationship slowed down the pace of the novel quite a bit. While I liked their story, I think it detracted from what was going on with the other characters. The novel would have been just as good (if not better) with just the usual introduction and epilogue from J.W. like readers were used to in the first two books. My other complaint is that there is a lot of repetition between the two journals. I understand that Fergus might have done this to make the accounts seem more authentic having been written independently of each other, but it got tiresome rereading dozens of pages about the exact same event from the chapter before. In most of these instances, May's and Molly's perspectives weren't different enough to really warrant so much repetition.

Those small issues aside, Strongheart is the perfect ending to such a memorable story. Save it for a time when you can read uninterrupted for hours because you're not going to want to put this down! 

My Rating: ★★★★☆

*Thanks to the author, St. Martin's Press, and Netgalley for providing me with a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Wednesday, February 10, 2021

Review: The Savage Instinct by Marjorie DeLuca

If you're into domestic suspense and historical fiction, then The Savage Instinct by Marjorie DeLuca should be your next read! (Readers should be aware that the novel has themes involving miscarriage, stillbirth, and violence against the incapacitated.) Set in Victorian England, the story follows Clara, a young wife who is released from an asylum for experiencing a violent display of emotion after delivering a stillborn baby. Her husband is more concerned with Clara's inheritance than her well-being and having her committed is the easiest solution to his money woes. Clara has to tread carefully as her husband and his companions plot and scheme to have her declared insane and locked away forever. 

One of Clara's hobbies is to read scriptures to women at the local prison. She is especially attached to Mary Ann Cotton, a real historical person who has been hailed as England's first female serial killer. Mary Ann is being tried for the murders of her husbands and many children via arsenic poisoning. Mary Ann's impending trial and sentencing are the backdrop for the tumultuous events in Clara's life. The novel has a slow build and there's plenty of infuriating "man talk" about how fragile and pathetic the female sex is, but there is plenty of suspense at the end to make this a worthwhile read. The ironic ending was unexpected. I'm interested to learn a bit more about the real Mary Ann Cotton after reading this book. I think fans of suspenseful historical fiction will enjoy this one!

My Rating: ★★★★☆

*Thanks to the author, Inkshares, and Netgalley for providing me with a digital ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Wednesday, January 13, 2021

Review: The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner

When done well, historical fiction can be pure magic! I can't think of a title I've read recently that has
gripped my attention so firmly as The Lost Apothecary by Sarah Penner. Everything about this novel is executed perfectly, from the authentic depictions of late 18th century London to the characterization of the three female protagonists. I've read that this is her novel debut and if that is true, Sarah Penner has quite a gift. Make this your next read and you will not be disappointed!

The storyline of Penner's tale seamlessly weaves together the lives of three remarkable women: Caroline, Nella, and Eliza. Caroline is a modern-day woman who discovers an old apothecary shop bottle while on a mudlarking tour in London. She's supposed to be enjoying a 10-year anniversary trip with her husband, but recent developments in their relationship resulted in this being a solo journey for Caroline. Researching the mysterious vial she's discovered serves to be the perfect distraction from dealing with the drama that has become her marriage. Her initial findings reveal a 200-year-old mystery surrounding an apothecary responsible for many poisoning deaths in the area. Determined to uncover as much information about this enigmatic woman as possible, Caroline soon makes another discovery that could possibly be the key to finally identifying London's first female serial killer.

The novel jumps back in time to tell Nella and Eliza's interconnected tale. Nella is the female apothecary who has a secret business on the side selling poisonous concoctions to women looking to get rid of the men in their lives. She conducts her business according to two simple rules: first, only men can be victims of her elixirs, never women and two, she must record every transaction in her registry. She writes down every transaction, including the names of the purchaser and the intended victim. One day, Eliza, a 12 year-old girl, shows up at Nella's shop looking to purchase a deadly remedy on her mistress's behalf. The intended recipient is the master of the house who has begun to cast his predatory eyes onto Eliza. Without knowing it, Nella and Eliza's paths will cross again, leading to an unexpected friendship and a cataclysmic event.

It's rare for me to like all the characters in a novel, but Penner created such a wonderful trio in Caroline, Nella, and Eliza that it was impossible not to love these women. I was rooting for Caroline to find her place in the world and even though the other two ladies passed away long ago, I still found myself hoping for them to have a happy ending. These characters will stay with me for a long time.

I was also delighted to find I learned a few new things while reading this novel. I had never heard of 'mudlarking' before and now I hope I can try it sometime because it sounds so fun! I'm sure I'll be disappointed at not finding a historical artifact right out of the gate like Caroline did, but either way, it sounds like a great experience. I also got a chance to learn some new vocabulary. Fun fact: the word 'apothecary' is used to refer to a person who sells medicines, much like a pharmacist or chemist today. I had always heard the term used to describe an old-timey pharmacy, but apparently it was more common to refer to a person as an apothecary and their place of business as an apothecary shop. Maybe that's already well-known, but I thought I'd share since it was news to me!

Overall, this was a fabulous read. I actually contemplated waking up EARLY after staying up late just so I could continue the story. I didn't end up doing that, but the fact I even seriously considered it should be a testament to how much I enjoyed this novel!

My Rating: ★★★★ out of 5

*Thanks to the author, Harper Audio, and Netgalley for providing me with this audiobook in exchange for an honest review!